Hot Take: Poached Eggs Are Pathetic

This week's hot take is all about how Lucas thinks the poached egg is the runt of the egg world and a dish that should be banned from all kitchens everywhere.
Poached eggs are pathetic website copy

I know that a lot of you disagree with me on most (read: all) of my hot takes but, even taking all of those terrible opinions into account, I reckon it’s my stance on poached eggs that tends to rile people up the most. Why? Because my stance on poached eggs is that they’re absolutely pathetic – a completely nothing food that’s incapable of exciting me in the slightest.

Aside from dropping it on the floor or chugging it in a glass like you're Rocky Balboa, poaching an egg is one of the worst things you can do to an egg. With its wispy whites and not-quite-warm-enough yolk, a poached egg is an absolute disservice to the simple and austere beauty of the egg. And I’m saying that as a certified Big Egg Guy™.

I eat eggs pretty much every day and firmly believe that they're one of the most wondrous foods in existence. Seriously. They’re a one-man-band capable of being turned into myriad marvellous dishes and possess a versatility that most other foodstuffs could only dream of. Eggs have got range, man. From its pivotal role in a silky chawanmushi to its scene-stealing turn in a saucy shakshuka, the egg is an ingredient that would make my "best foods" awards shortlist every year. That's probably why I find the concept of poaching an egg to be so upsetting. It’s a bit like boiling a choice cut of steak.

The crux of the matter is that there’s no situation where a poached egg is the best egg preparation for the job and, whenever you order one at a restaurant, it pretty much always arrives in the same predictable fashion. Which is as a sad, wet lump of anaemic-looking albumen – heaped on top of a triangle of toast – which slowly dampens that once-crisp bread until the whole thing is an indistinguishable soggy mess.

I’d take a runny fried egg, a jammy soft boiled egg, or a scrambled egg over a poached egg any day. Hell, I’d even opt for a hard-boiled egg if you put a gun to my head and asked me which I’d prefer to eat for breakfast. Which, let’s be honest, is quite an intense thing to do, mate.

Not only am I not a fan of wasting a meal out on a poached egg, but I haven’t even got to the fact that cooking them at home is a faff that’s rarely worth the effort. You’ll hear people tell you to add vinegar to your water; you’ll hear people use the word “vortex” an unreasonable number of times; and you’ll hear people telling you to wrap each individual egg in cling film like its sort of new-age saran wrap mummy. If any of those techniques work for you: that’s great. But I’ve tried them all and none have offered me any sort of consistency in my poached egg production. They're always shit.

I suppose you’re probably thinking that I’m a bit of a diva at this point. You're probably also thinking that the only reason that I really consider poached eggs to be pathetic is that when it boils down to it – pun very much intended – I’m simply not very good at cooking them. That means you're probably also thinking something along the lines of: "hey, maybe it's Lucas that's actually the pathetic one because he can’t do a task as simple as poaching an egg and he's had to write a whole column complaining about how bad they are to cover up for his own failings as a home cook". Well, guess what? You’d be absolutely 100% correct.

Poached eggs are pathetic

Related Content

Just Add An Egg
MOB Contributor Marcus Brown discusses why adding an egg to a meal can turn it from a mediocre meal into a dish you can't (and won't) stop thinking about.
10 Best Kitchen Tools Under £10
Want to improve your kitchen skills without breaking the bank? These useful kitchen tools all cost less than a tenner. Your next impulse purchase awaits.
How To Open A Restaurant
Want to know how to open a restaurant? We asked some brilliant restaurateurs for their best pieces of advice about getting into the industry.
The Best Restaurants in Manchester
Looking for somewhere to eat in Manchester? You’re in the right place. From sandwich pop-ups to Stockport staples, these are the best restaurants in Manchester.
Where To Drink Natural Wine in London | 29 Great Wine Bars To Try
These are the best natural wine bars and restaurants in the city. From Hector’s to Bright, your next pét nat party is sorted.
12 Low-Alcohol Beers You Should Be Drinking
After some alcohol-free and low alcohol beers that don’t taste like a metallic disappointment? You’ve come to the right place for a fun and sober time, MOB.